top of page

$695,000 Settlement for Three Huntington Beach Households in a Toxic Exposure and Habitability Case

Strongin, LLP
Oct 5
5 min read

Updated: Oct 7

In February 2026, Strongin, LLP reached a $695,000 settlement on behalf of three Huntington Beach households in a toxic exposure and habitability case against their former landlord and its property management company. The plaintiffs were represented by Kseniya Y. Stupak of Strongin, LLP.

BEHIND THE WALLS OF CASA DEL SOL

The scream came from the guest bathroom.


It was January 2024, and Darlene Cacucciolo ran toward the sound. Inside Unit 175 at

the Casa Del Sol Apartments, on Brookhurst Street in Huntington Beach, part of the

bathroom wall had given way. Her four-year-old son sat on the toilet, pieces of damp

drywall on top of him.


She lifted him off, washed him down, and brushed the crumbling board away with her

bare hands. The drywall was wet and, she would later learn, laced with mold. Repair

crews arrived the next day. According to court filings, the family was told to vacate on

short notice, with no hotel, no replacement unit, and no help with costs. The

Cacucciolos spent roughly three weeks in an extended-stay hotel at their own expense.

They were still charged full rent.


For the Cacucciolos and two of their neighbors, the collapsed wall was not the

beginning of the story. It was proof of what they had been saying for years.


A KNOCK ON A LAW FIRM'S DOOR

Evan Alexander made the first call. He had rented Unit 166 since 2017. On New Year's

Eve 2021, he came home from the holidays to find a half-finished shower replacement

and an open bathroom wall dark with mold. When he asked management to stop work

until the mold could be tested, he woke the next morning to maintenance workers in his

apartment. Days later, according to court filings, he was served with a three-day notice

to let them finish or move out.


In early 2022, Alexander contacted Strongin, LLP. He did not come empty-handed. He

had already paid for his own laboratory testing.


Word traveled down the hallways. By May 2022, the Cacucciolo family in Unit 175

(Darlene, her husband Mark, and their two young children) had joined him. RaeAnn

Clark, a former tenant of Unit 142 who had moved out in late 2021, joined the lawsuit in

early 2024.


"These families did everything tenants are supposed to do," said Kseniya Stupak, a

partner at Strongin, LLP. "They reported the leaks. They paid for their own testing. They

sent the results to management."



WATER, THEN MOLD, THEN PAINT

The three units told the same story in different rooms.


In Unit 166, three large floods swept through Alexander's kitchen, dining room, and

living room in the fall of 2021, leaving them nearly unusable. When he hired his own

inspectors in early 2022, the results were stark. One laboratory measured 350,000

spores per square centimeter of Chaetomium, a mold associated with water-damaged

buildings, in his bathroom. Later rounds of testing found Aspergillus, Penicillium, and

Stachybotrys, the mold commonly called black mold, inside his walls and ceiling.

Moisture readings reached 99 percent. Coliform bacteria turned up under the kitchen

sink and beneath the carpet.


In mid-2022, Alexander was moved to a hotel while his unit was remediated. When he

returned that July, the families alleged, the visible mold was still there, water was

seeping up through the floorboards, and some of his belongings, including a violin, had

been thrown away. A city code enforcement officer inspected the unit that fall. Alexander

moved out in March 2023.


Elsewhere in the complex, in Unit 175, the Cacucciolos first noticed what Darlene

described as "mushrooms" growing from the bathroom in the summer of 2021. By

spring 2022, independent testing found black mold in the air of both bathrooms and

behind the kitchen sink. An inspector's report called the apartment uninhabitable under

California law. Broken pipes kept flooding the carpets. The family, which had lived at the

complex for years, did not leave until June 2025.


In Unit 142, RaeAnn Clark reported a bathroom ceiling leak in May 2019 and, according

to court filings, heard nothing for more than two months while the plaster bubbled. In

August 2021, a leaking sink and dishwasher flooded her kitchen. When maintenance

pulled the dishwasher out, the wall behind it was black with mold. The fix, the families

alleged, was to wipe it down and paint over it with Kilz.


Clark sent her own samples to a lab. They came back positive for Stachybotrys,

Chaetomium, and other species. She reported the results to the Orange County Health

Care Agency, which notified the landlord on September 27, 2021. Two days later,

according to court filings, the landlord served Clark with a three-day notice to perform or

quit over matters unrelated to the mold. She moved out that November.


California law requires landlords to keep rental housing habitable, including sound

plumbing and effective waterproofing (Civ. Code, § 1941.1), and treats dampness and

visible mold that threaten health as substandard conditions (Health & Saf. Code, §

17920.3). The families alleged that Casa Del Sol's owner and manager relied on

untrained handymen to patch and paint rather than hire licensed remediation

professionals.


WHAT THE MOLD TOOK FROM THEM

For each household, the cost showed up first in their bodies.


Evan Alexander described a slow fog settling over his life: difficulty breathing,

dizziness, lightheadedness, drowsiness, and fatigue. He reported trouble thinking

clearly, depression, watery eyes, constant congestion, and more frequent asthma

attacks. Urine testing detected mycotoxins, including ochratoxin, a toxin produced by

some Aspergillus species, the same genus found in his apartment. He now uses an

inhaler every day.


The Cacucciolo family lived with the symptoms longest. Darlene made repeated trips

to the emergency room for shortness of breath that, she said, doctors could not explain.

The family reported coughing, wheezing, headaches and migraines, allergies, rashes,

dizziness, anxiety, and depression. Her husband, Mark, who often worked out of state,

noticed that his cough and sneezing came back only when he was home. Their

daughter put her hand through a wet bathroom wall and, the family said, broke out in a

red, burning rash; she has since been treated for chronic headaches and allergies.

Their young son, who has special needs, developed allergies, croup, and headaches,

and the forced moves out of the apartment were especially hard on him.


RaeAnn Clark moved into Unit 142 with mild asthma that did not require an inhaler. By

the time she left, she reported a persistent cough, worsening asthma, heavy sinus

congestion, stomach and digestive problems, debilitating headaches, memory loss, and

fatigue. Her own testing detected ochratoxin in her urine and Cladosporium in a nasal

culture. According to court filings, her physicians linked many of her symptoms,

including a bout of pneumonia, to mold exposure. She, too, now relies on an inhaler

every day.


The damage did not stop at their health. The families alleged they threw out furniture,

clothing, and other belongings contaminated by mold, paid out of pocket for hotels and

testing, and kept paying rent the whole time.


THREE YEARS IN COURT

Strongin, LLP filed suit in Orange County Superior Court on September 5, 2023, against

the property's owners, Casa Apartments, LP and Casa Apartments GP, LLC, and its

manager, DFT, Inc., doing business as Cannon Management. The complaint alleged

breach of the implied warranty of habitability, nuisance, negligence, constructive

eviction, premises liability, and intentional infliction of emotional distress, and later

added fraud by concealment.


The case moved through written discovery, expert inspections, and depositions of

current and former Cannon Management staff. In September 2024, the firm mailed

letters to Casa Del Sol residents asking anyone with evidence of leaks or mold to come forward. Defendants sought more than once to push back the trial date. The families

opposed, and trial was set for March 9, 2026.


It never got that far. At a mandatory settlement conference in February 2026, the parties

reached a global resolution: $695,000 for the three households.


For families who spent years being told there was no mold, the result carried weight

beyond the dollar figure.


Disclaimer: This case result is provided for informational purposes only and does not guarantee a similar outcome in any future matter. Every case is different and depends on its specific facts, evidence, and applicable law.

YOU NEED A LAWYER THAT CAN HELP. STRONGIN, LLP OFFERS FREE CASE EVALUATIONS.

Please take a moment to tell us what happened. Our lawyers will review the records and contact you to discuss the next steps.

​

Call (949) 529-2250 or complete the form below.

Address

999 Corporate Drive
Suite 220
Ladera Ranch, CA 92694

Phone

(949) 529-2250

Email

Social Media

  • TikTok
  • Yelp!
  • LinkedIn
  • Youtube
  • Instagram
  • Facebook

© 2026 Strongin, LLP

Any testimonial or endorsement, including those found on this website or anywhere else, does not constitute a guarantee, warranty, or prediction regarding the outcome of your legal matter.

bottom of page